Lorenzetti’s Allegory of Good Government, 1339
We’re number one. That’s what we always tell each other.
We have the best health care in the world.
Our public safety institutions are number one in the world.
We are the richest country in the world.
We are supremely over confident.
How many people know that when Dr. Kent Brantley and Nancy Writebol returned from Liberia with ebola that their care was paid for by Samaritan’s Purse? I’ll bet a lot of us just assumed that the US government picked up the tab for the flight, biocontainment units, ZMapp doses and hospital stays. Not so. So, who is paying for the transport and treatment of Nina Pham and Amber Vinson?
Probably a few more of us have questioned whether money was behind the shoddy care that Mr. Duncan got in Texas. I have. I’m betting that his lack of insurance and status as a foreign national had a lot to do with why he wasn’t immediately isolated when he first came to the hospital and why he was left in the ER for hours, some nurses say days, before he was transferred to a critical care unit.
As for the best health care in the world, the nurses were very unprepared for ebola. The biggest chunk of the blame goes to the hospital. It’s a hospital for the middle class and those who can afford the best health care in the world. That’s where people go to have their babies and bypass operations. Maybe they didn’t associate their kind of hospital with an epidemic in a third world country. Bad things happen to THOSE people over there in Africa. Not their kind of people in Dallas. At best, that’s a benign form of American narcissism. We’re so used to having clean water and streets and good food. So, why should the hospital get all Girl Scouty and be prepared for a situation that will never happen to it? Training for such an eventuality takes time from nurses doing their duties and time is money. It’s the American way.
The CDC seems to have vastly overestimated the outcomes of our educational institutions, especially our K-12 schools, where everyone should have a pretty good understanding as to where Liberia is. But then again, Liberia was a state created by former American slaves in the 19th century and Texas is a state notorious for trying to rewrite the past when white Americans might have done bad stuff to anyone. But still, don’t these ER intake people, nurses and doctors watch the news?? At least one nursing supervisor seems to have been on the ball and insisted on moving Mr. Duncan to an isolation unit instead of letting him shed viruses all over the ER but she was shot down by her administration. Still, you’d think that a hospital so concerned with its reputation and profits would have been more proactive in limiting the damage that his presence was causing. Not so, apparently.
And what was the hospital thinking when they gave antibiotics to Duncan when they hadn’t bothered to find out whether he had a bacterial infection that required them? Does Texas Health Presby Hospital routinely overprescribe antibiotics? Is this a hospital or a student health center?
What were Republicans and Democrats thinking when they cut the budget for the CDC by 12% and the NIH by 20%? Friedan said yesterday that $30 million was restored earlier this year in an “anomaly”. How the hell are you supposed to prepare for emergencies if you never know what your budget is going to be from one year to the next? We complain about administrators making decisions for our health care instead of physicians but our bigger problem is that we have politicians making decisions for our disease fighting institutions. Should the CDC and NIH know in advance what diseases are going to become epidemic on some kind of 5 year plan and ask for the right budget money in advance? Or are their functions compromised by their unreadiness brought on by this reckless political posturing?
And everyone, politicians, journalists and people who should know better, is under some mistaken belief that the private sector is going to step up and perform the tasks in research and disease prevention that the CDC and NIH were created to do. But they’re too busy trying to reap profits for the shareholders to engage in such money sucking activities like research. Meanwhile, we underfund the NIH and CDC. Is that so Republicans can point to what a sh*%%y job government does? Are they paying no attention to how our scientific infrastructure is being dismantled in this country and concentrated on a few narrow therapeutic areas? They are leaving a gap that no one is able to fill.
This may be the richest country in the world but the riches are hoarded by some pretty selfish individuals and we don’t seem to be able to get our act together to force them to give up their loot for the greater good.
A little ray of hope came through yesterday when I saw that some television content providers are breaking away from the package deals offered by cable companies to allow viewers ala carte channel selection. That’s great because eventually I will no longer have to subsidize right wing propaganda from Fox News or be forced to pay for Fox to mislead unsuspecting American viewers. I’m betting that a lot of like minded individuals across the country will drop Fox from their lineup the second they are able to do it.
But the damage may already be done. The Senate may fall into Republican hands this November and in the next two years, the predators who have been stalking us since FDR got us out of the Great Depression will finally be able to finish us off. The willfully ignorant elderly and angry white males will finally stick a fork in us, and allow the extremists to carelessly destroy Social Security, roll back women’s rights and plunge us back into recession with unrestrained austerity. The only thing that will stand between the power extremists and us will be Barack Obama. That right there is a very depressing scenario. But maybe he will have the courage to stand aside when we finally pick up our torches and pitchforks.
We have been living a myth of our greatness. We’ve been in denial about how government works. We have told ourselves lies about how we can “starve the beast” that once made our country a formidable force of good around the world.
I’m only glad that the ebola crisis here will be under control before the next session of Congress begins and before the gung-ho, American exceptionalists who take over show us just how unexceptional we are to the hunters who prey on the young, old, and weak.
Section from Lorenzetti’s Effects of Bad Government, 1339
More speculation and budget numbers at Angry Bear Blog.
Filed under: General | Tagged: American exceptionalism, budgets, CDC, congress, Dallas, ebola, Liberia, NIH, Samaritan's Purse, Senate, Texas | 26 Comments »