This morning, Paul Krugman had a guest poster, Kim Lane Scheppele, to explain what is going on in Hungary. Remember how excited we were 20 years ago when Hungary escaped the tyrannical clutches of Communism? Unfortunately, they have fallen into the hands of what looks like fascism:
In a free and fair election last spring in Hungary, the center-right political party, Fidesz, got 53% of the vote. This translated into 68% of the seats in the parliament under Hungary’s current disproportionate election law. With this supermajority, Fidesz won the power to change the constitution. They have used this power in the most extreme way at every turn, amending the constitution ten times in their first year in office and then enacting a wholly new constitution that will take effect on January 1, 2012.
[…]
In the new constitutional system, the legal supervision of elections has also been changed. Before the last election, the norm was for the five-member Election Commission to be politically diverse and for the government of the day to consult the opposition before nominating candidates. But the rules were changed last year so that each new national election is now accompanied by a new choice of election commissioners. As a result, the existing commissioners were removed from their offices without allowing them to finish their terms and now the Election Commission consists of five members of the governing party.
The new election law specifies the precise boundaries of the new electoral districts that will send representatives to the parliament. But the new districts are drawn in such a way that no other party on the political horizon besides Fidesz is likely to win elections. A respected Hungarian think tank ran the numbers from the last three elections using the new district boundaries. Fidesz would have won all three elections, including the two they actually lost.
The new constitution also accepts conservative Christian social doctrine as state policy, in a country where only 21% of the population attends any religious services at all. The fetus is protected from the moment of conception. Marriage is only legal if between a man and a woman. The constitution “recognize(s) the role of Christianity in preserving nationhood” and holds that “the family and the nation constitute the principal framework of our coexistence.” While these religious beliefs are hard-wired into the constitution, a new law on the status of religion cut the number of state-recognized churches to only fourteen, deregistering 348 other churches.

About Occupy: On Saturday, as the Bishop was scaling a fence in his magenta cassock, someone with the system password put up a greeting from Mumia Abu-Jamal on the OccupyWallSt.org page. At first, I was pretty pissed off. It seems that no matter how hard ordinary people who are not authoritarian religious nutcases try to defend a different point of view, they are always brought to a screeching halt by naive defenders of Mumia Abu-Jamal. I have seen it so many times in the past couple of decades that I feel a deep sense of despair when this kind of crap shows up again. Suddenly, no matter if you are against a stupid war or against indefinite detentions or rigged elections or any other important thing, you are conscripted to defend this convicted murderer. It’s at that point that the people whose support you need the most decide that your cause is just another crazy radical fling that will go the way of the other fling.
Most of the world thinks Mumia is just where he is supposed to be right now. There was plenty of evidence to convict him. But whatever. Just when you think a movement is about to go mainstream, some nitwit has to start emoting over Mumia, as if there weren’t other disadvantaged and poorly represented African-American men and women wrongly imprisoned and innocent. It’s been thirty years and Mumia, the celebrity prisoner, is still attracting a cadre of followers who cannot see that just because a person was a Black Panther at some point in his life does not mean that the world is out to pin murders on him and put him away for life. Sometimes, a cold-blooded murder of a police officer is just a cold-blooded murder of a police officer. We don’t attack the police even if they’re complete thuggish assholes sometimes (no offense). When you need them, they’re usually there for you. That doesn’t make them our best friends but it does mean that we need to treat each other with respect even if we have to be civilly disobedient.
So, Mumia represents everything the Occupiers are against and I was really worried that the support for Mumia was going to be the downfall of OWS. In fact, I wrote emails begging them to take Mumia’s greeting down.
But, you know what? That was the wrong thing to do. Because I checked the thread on that greeting yesterday and the vast majority of people thought like I did. Here’s the top comment on that thread with plenty of mojo:
I have been working at Occupy Wall Street since week 2. I am involved heavily in several working groups. I attend meetings and actions every day of the week. But this? This is bullshit. Here’s the thing y’all. Yes, the criminal justice system is brutally unfair. It is racist. It is classist. It is broken beyond all repair. The prison industrial complex has swallowed any hopes that a poor black man ever had to a right to a fair trial in this country. HOWEVER, Mumia? Mumia is guilty as hell. Guilty, guilty, guilty. He stood over Officer Daniel Faulkner with a gun registered in his own name and shot him point blank in the face in front of multiple witnesses. Because of Mumia’s involvement with The Black Panthers, because of his background as a guerilla journalist, and because of the undoubtedly racist climate of Frank Rizzo’s police department in the 1980’s, Mumia’s conviction became a cause celibre. I do not believe in the death penalty. I think that our justice system is a sham. But slapping Mumia’s face on the front of the OWS website is insulting and offensive to all of us who have worked so hard these past few months. This movement is about socio-economic inequality and corporate corruption. It is not about promoting the latest Free Mumia rally on campus. Please show some respect for the legions of us who have put in so much time, and do not glorify the convicted murderer of a police officer. No matter how many college kids wear his face on their shirts.
They are occupiers and have dedicated time and their presence to the occupation. They are just average folks and they do not want the occupation to be associated with Mumia. It’s pretty definitive. Yes, there are a few vocal and persistent supporters but their obsession is not that of the vast majority of occupiers. The occupation is to save America, not to give Mumia Abu-Jamal a platform to proclaim his innocence and unfair incarceration due to his political beliefs from 30 years ago.
I’m really rather encouraged. This is the way the system is supposed to work. Give everyone a voice and let the conversation and arguments carry the day. It is regrettable that Mumia was convicted of being in the wrong place at the time when a police officer was gunned down and that Mumia was seen shooting the cop, and that he owned the gun that was used to shoot the cop, and that he was in turn shot by the cop, and that he pretty much confessed to shooting the cop to other cops and medical technicians before he was taken in for surgery, or that he tried to represent himself in court and did such a lousy job of it that he had to be replaced as his own defense attorney before he did real damage to his case. He’s had his day in court and his appeals and many opportunities to change public opinion and he’s still in jail. There’s a reason for that.
All these things are regrettable, but they are not our problem. If Mumia was such a good guy, such a saint who shared our concerns for economic and social justice, he would refrain from ruining every attempt to get something off the ground by inserting his “greetings” and attempting to co-opt a movement to work in his defense. To me, he sounds like a narcissist.
Our problem is finding a place to occupy, to protest and to voice our grievances about economic injustice and the rigging of the rules in favor of the rich and powerful to the detriment of everyone else no matter how hard working. Our task is to invite others to join us. Our task is to become a force to be reckoned with. Once we have solved our own problems, which affect millions of people in this country, those who are concerned with the plight of Mumia can turn their attention to it. But leave the rest of us out of it.
The community seems to be pretty much agreed on that.
And here’s a little video of the activities of December 17. I’m sorry to have missed this one. Bishop Packard’s attire was lovely.
Filed under: General | Tagged: Hungary, Kim Lane Scheppele, Mumia Abu-Jamal, Occupy Bus, occupy congress, occupy wall street, Paul Krugman, Washington | 9 Comments »