• Tips gratefully accepted here. Thanks!:

  • Recent Comments

    riverdaughter on And so it begins…
    lililam on Somewhat Brief Reflections
    Propertius on And so it begins…
    insightanalytical on And so it begins…
    Propertius on Somewhat Brief Reflections
    Propertius on Somewhat Brief Reflections
    Ivory Bill Woodpecke… on Today’s bright spot
    Ivory Bill Woodpecke… on Somewhat Brief Reflections
    Ga6thDem on Somewhat Brief Reflections
    Propertius on Somewhat Brief Reflections
    Propertius on Somewhat Brief Reflections
    Propertius on Somewhat Brief Reflections
    Seagrl on Somewhat Brief Reflections
    Ga6thDem on Somewhat Brief Reflections
    Ga6thDem on Somewhat Brief Reflections
  • Categories

  • Tags

    abortion Add new tag Afghanistan Al Franken Anglachel Atrios bankers Barack Obama Bernie Sanders big pharma Bill Clinton cocktails Conflucians Say Dailykos Democratic Party Democrats Digby DNC Donald Trump Donna Brazile Economy Elizabeth Warren feminism Florida Fox News General Glenn Beck Glenn Greenwald Goldman Sachs health care Health Care Reform Hillary Clinton Howard Dean John Edwards John McCain Jon Corzine Karl Rove Matt Taibbi Media medicare Michelle Obama Michigan misogyny Mitt Romney Morning Edition Morning News Links Nancy Pelosi New Jersey news NO WE WON'T Obama Obamacare OccupyWallStreet occupy wall street Open thread Paul Krugman Politics Presidential Election 2008 PUMA racism Republicans research Sarah Palin sexism Single Payer snark Social Security Supreme Court Terry Gross Texas Tim Geithner unemployment Wall Street WikiLeaks women
  • Archives

  • History

    December 2010
    S M T W T F S
  • RSS Paul Krugman: Conscience of a Liberal

  • The Confluence

    The Confluence

  • RSS Suburban Guerrilla

  • RSS Ian Welsh

    • Open Thread
      Use comments to discuss topics unrelated to recent posts. Facebook Twitter WhatsApp LinkedIn
  • Top Posts

Thursday: overslept

You may have to jump

“If you board the wrong train, it is no use running along the corridor in the other direction.”
— Dietrich Bonhoeffer

Just sayin’.  You can discover more about Dietrich Bonhoeffer at this Speaking of Faith podcast.

Right to Lifer gunman kills two at Boston abortion clinics.  Time to take matters into your own hands, ladies and get government out of your uterus.  Go underground.

Tennessee Guerilla Women posted this movie trailer the other day about what women face in this country.  Funny how you tend to get used to this crap.

500 years, eh?  Well. *that* sucks.  What we need is a woman starting her OWN network, delivering the news in a gender neutral fashion, you know someone like Oprah.

Oh wait, she was the one who gave us Obama.  Nevermind.

The New York Times reports that the nomination of the next Republican candidate for president may be out of the party’s hands.  Yeah, and I’ve got a bridge in Brooklyn.  Are you kidding me?  Republicans are the ultimate control freaks.  I take that back.  The 2008 DEMOCRATS were the ultimate control freaks.  If Hillary had been running in the Republican primaries in 2008, she would have had the whole thing sewn up on superdupertuesday and Obama would have spent the next four years in the Senatorial obscurity he was showing such a talent for.

Tom Watson has a review of the book “You Are Not a Gadget” by Jaron Lanier.  Watson argues that Lanier’s point is that social networking technology has the capacity to dehumanize us and makes us vulnerable to those who seek power.  I would argue that that has already happened (see quote at top of page).  Here’s the money quote from Watson’s review:

Lanier’s point is that by reducing personality and the wide sweep of human thought into chunks that can fit easily into databases and digested through clever widely-popular front end designs, the possibility for horrific “crowd-sourced” activity is that much greater. To put it simply, the good guys don’t always win. Throughout history, they’ve often been shouted down by crowds. While it’s impossible to argue with the sunny opening lines of the introduction to Yochai Benkler’s seminal Internet text The Wealth of Networks – “Information, knowledge and culture are central to human freedom and human development” – and to sympathize with a point of view that argues that great access to those qualities improves the lot of mankind, Lanier’s warnings also seem in tune with the times.

It’s not crazy to worry that, with millions of people connected through a medium that sometimes brings out their worst tendencies, massive, fascist-style mobs could rise up suddenly. I worry about the next generation of young people around the world growing up with internet-based technology that emphasizes crowd aggregation, as is the current fad. Will they be more likely to succumb to pack dynamics when they come of age?

That kind of thinking flies in the face of a more utopian view of free information, embodied in hacker philosopher Richard Stallman’s famous ’90s proclamation that when “information is generally useful, redistributing it makes humanity wealthier no matter who is distributing and no matter who is receiving.” I’d naturally ask “what does generally useful mean?” and Lanier goes a step further, noting that the free flow of information also brings large-scale vitriol to arguments between semi-anonymous actors on the Net. “What’s to prevent the acrimony from scaling up? Unfortunately, history tells us that collectivist ideas can mushroom into large-scale social disasters.”

My question is how do we alert the general public to let the Tweeter beware?

Mecca is becoming the Las Vegas of Saudi Arabia.  High on tacky kitsch, low on fun?  There won’t be any commercials with the tag line, “What happens on Hajj, stays in Mecca”.

E. J. Dionne is running down the corridor as he tries to rehabilitate Obama in Rekindling Hope in Liberalism.  He uses the standard whiny reason:

For the president’s loyalists, of course, this indictment is profoundly unfair. He inherited a mess at home and abroad. The economic downturn began on Bush’s watch, but its bitter fruits were harvested after Obama took office. By contrast, Franklin Roosevelt took power after Herbert Hoover had presided over three of the most miserable years in American economic history. Blame was firmly fixed on Hoover by the time FDR showed up with his jaunty smile and contagious optimism.

And, yes, there is the small issue of Obama’s real achievements, the health care law above all. If insuring 32 million more Americans is not an enormous social reform, then nothing can be said to count as change. The now well-rehearsed list of additional accomplishments — from Wall Street and student loan reform to the end of “don’t ask, don’t tell” to the simple fact that the economy’s catastrophic slide was halted and reversed — would, in the abstract, do any administration proud.

I would have written that first line of the second paragraph as “And, yes, there is the real issue of Obama’s small achievements…” E. J. is still clinging to the idea that no one could have known how bad it was going to be so it was perfectly reasonable to nominate the candidate with the least practical experience in our lifetimes to become president.  I simply can’t take this reasoning seriously when the poor performance was avoidable.  But the E.J. goes one better and has the nerve to lecture *us*:

And both the liberals and Obama need to escape the bubbles of legislative and narrowly ideological politics and re-engage the country on what can only be called a spiritual level. Modern American liberalism is not some abstract and alien creed. At its best, it marries a practical, get-things-done approach to government with a devotion to fairness, justice and compassion. These sentiments are grounded in the nation’s religious traditions and also in our commitment to community-building that Alexis de Tocqueville so appreciated.

Stop laughing.  Yes, he really said this.  E.J. needs to get out of his own bubble.  The “achievements” aren’t.  By practical standards, the health care reform bill was a bomb.  The mandate was an outrage in the absence of competition.  If you have stagnant wages and fear that you’re going to lose your job, the last thing you need is yet another expense you can’t afford that doesn’t result in something better than you already had.  The TARP bills rescued the banks and left everyone else hold the bag.  The stimulus bill was too small.  HAMP is almost criminal.

I don’t know who the hell E.J. has been talking to but from a practical, non-abstract, working class POV, this president has been an abject failure.  You don’t have to be a liberal to realize that but liberals have every reason to have expected better than this.  I don’t believe in the self-esteem movement where everyone gets a gold star for trying.  I believe you have no right to think you’re the greatest thing since sliced bread until you’ve proven yourself. Republicans aren’t becoming suddenly sexy again because regular Americans are crazy about conservatism .  There are two reasons why Republicans are winning: 1.) Americans don’t buy the boosterism of the current administration.  No one believes in Recovery Summer or Recovery Fall or Recovery Winter or whatever nonsense they’re spouting this week.  They’re believing their lying eyes. and 2.) When your base stays home in disgust, that leaves the  Fox News viewers who have been emotionalized by Glenn Beck and abortion as the motivated voters who actually go to the polls.

You can’t reason the Democrats’ failures away by blaming the voters’ perceptions, E.J.  What the Democrats need to do if they want to recapture the public is to start acting more like Democrats.  Ooops!  Too late, they’ve lost the House and they’re preemptively capitulating before the Republicans even officially take over.  Don’t think the public doesn’t notice.

What the public *might* notice is Ed Rendell. Yeah, I think the idea of football being played in a blizzard is sort of stupid too.  But this is Philadelphia.  It’s not a city of wusses.  And Ed Rendell may be the rough and tough, unibrowed Democrat the party needs to man up.  BTW, that’s just a figure of speech.  Apparently, Ed Rendell plucks his brows.  And this is not an endorsement.  It’s just an idle speculation.

But I do take issue with some of this articles’ points.  For example, Ed probably did say  “that his state was full of “conservative whites” who were “probably not ready to vote for an African- American candidate.”  This is true.  There are a lot of areas in the middle of the state that fly confederate flags on their porches.  HOWEVER, those porches belong to Republicans.  How do I know that?  I talked to the canvassers who visited those areas.  They had the party affiliation sheets with the addresses.  The Democrats that I spoke to while phone banking in Harrisburg were of the opinion that they wanted an experienced person in the White House.  They were hurt that people were calling them bigots and they said they were willing to vote for Obama some time down the road.  So, Ed really needs to be clear about who his constituents are and what they are thinking.

Things to keep your eye on:  Senator Bernie Sanders, of filibernie fame, will be on Thom Hartmann’s show today to discuss the year in review.  The schedule thingy looks a little chaotic to me so check back periodically for the stream.

42 Responses

  1. I see that everyone else has overslept as well.

  2. La-la-la-la-la, which room will I clean today?

  3. I kinda like your Ed speculation.

  4. (overslept!) Ha!

    I’m going for a walk — I’ll be back soon!!

  5. ya’ know, when the number “32 million more insured”… I have to wonder if that is a “possible number” or an actual number?

    can those 32 million actually AFFORD health insurance?

    • Um, no. My insurance is going up next year as well. It will probably cancel out the 2% break in the payroll tax.

    • My family benefits from the health care reform because AT&T is now covering all dependent children to 26, rather than only full-time students to 22. One of our sons will regain insurance on Jan. 1. I assume other large companies are doing the same thing, and that some states might allow parents to obtain SCHIP insurance for older children. I don’t think that would come up to 32 million, but I’m sure there are a lot of young adults who now have greater access to affordable insurance. Our rates and co-pays have increased, but we’re part of the lucky few who are better off (for the moment) with the new laws. Unfortunately, it doesn’t do anything for the unemployed or those who don’t have good or affordable insurance through their employers. Why not Medicare for all?

  6. Third parties in Philly. If the Ds were electorally responsive, they’d react. They aren’t, so they’ll try kabuki. FAIL.

  7. What is that E. J. Dionne smoking anyway? Or is there payment involved? That crap just doesn’t make any sense, even if you’re a full on kool-aid IV’er. Just a wee bit over the top there E.J.

    • Let me guess: He and the other liberals screwed up and got behind the wrong guy. But they can’t admit it because that would make them look stupid and less punditty.
      Actually, you’re right. EJ isn’t even trying in this one. It’s like word salad.
      the job must have some nice percs

  8. Overslept … or depressed? Videos like the “Miss Representation” one always makes me terribly sad. What a perpetually uphill battle we fight.

    So good for theTel Aviv District Court for finally convicting the former Israeli President Moshe Katsav of rape and sexual assault.

    The verdict read out by the panel of three judges – Karra, Miriam Sokolov and Judith Shevach – was the first judicial statement on the veracity of allegations repeated, dissected and mulled over by the Israeli population and the media for the past four years.

    After an initial attempt to have the reading of the verdict closed to the media, the main substance of the ruling was read in open court, but how much of the verdict was actually to be released for publication will be decided only after the state submits its position on the matter.

    Out of concern for the complainants’ privacy, much of the trial had taken place behind closed doors.

    Of course, as is customary in rape cases involving a prominent person, the “population and the media” doesn’t need much – or any – “released for publication” material to dissect in miniscule, intimate detail what (they don’t really know!) went on.

    Wonder if someone will now dig up a report that takes Israel to task for having an “abysmally low conviction rate for rape cases” and use that report as evidence that the only reason Israel went after Katsav was because of who he is?

    • No, SERIOUSLY, I overslept.
      I wouldn’t get depressed over the video. Evolution sometimes happens rapidly.
      It *almost* happened in 2008, which just goes to show that the first woman to break through is going to have to put up with a lot of shit but the public will have the final say.
      It will happen. Probably sooner than later.

    • Think that movie was made by Gavin Newsome’s wife Jennifer. She’s taking it to Sundance. I don’t like it because it’s Obama friendly, and he’s part of the problem re sexism today in America in my view.

  9. Love Bernie. Thom’s a fricking nutcase. I don’t know what’s wrong with Thom, but he can’t think his way out of a wet paper back when it comes to economics and history and has the worst case of CDS I’ve ever seen. But other than that… 🙂

    • I don’t listen to Thom but Bernie is wonderfully passionate and succinct. I’d listen to him any day.

  10. I think if you have to reach back to that Alexis de Tocqueville to show a liberal with compassion, you’ve already lost the argument.

    . I worry about the next generation of young people around the world growing up with internet-based technology that emphasizes crowd aggregation, as is the current fad. Will they be more likely to succumb to pack dynamics when they come of age?

    Dude, this already happened. Weren’t you paying attention in 2008?

    • Good point. That is what was used by the “movement of hate” that was the Obama campaign.

    • {{snort!}}
      EJ is really behind on the pack dynamics. We’ve already been burned.
      Still, I do know what he fears. And he has a right to fear it. But he’s not heading off this eventuality by sticking with Obama and calling him liberal.
      Time to jump off the train, EJ.

  11. Great video, RD from Tennessee. One of the pushes in the era we grew up was extreme empowerment for young girls. The book that I wrote, Heart of Clouds (has fingers crossed on LA editor right now) addresses themes in the video above. The boy character Devlin likes the “naturalness” of the Teenie Alexander character. I’m going to grow the girl up the way we grew up

    Just this morning in the news was the death of the anorexic model. A new word to Google — “pro-ana”
    will be addressing that in a character very soon. Google the images on that, Conf. people.

    Gen Jones women need to write a feminism for these little girls, soon. It’s B’s gen. Am writing interventions into text via characters…

    ps: on the Twitter deal. Very strange how mob mentality looks…what it does in terms of crowdsourcing…

    hugs, wishes all a peaceful New Year…& not too many snowstorms…

  12. SF Mayor, Gavin Newsom’s wife, Jennifer Siebel Newsom is responsible for that doc, Miss Representation.

    Hillary supporters trying to change the world. 😉

    • Oops…Meant to include this quote in there too from a poster at Tennessee’s site. The post was intended to read a bit more snarky though I do appreciate the doc.

      Samanthasmom – “Unfortunately, some of the women commenting are also perpetrators.”

      • Been trying to encourage her to bring up 2008 more re Palin and Hillary as she tours with the film. Her promoters seem to be more Obot like.

        • Sigh.

          Do any of them understand what they’ve done? To the country – let alone to the cause they are promoting?

          Why did the man with less experience trump Hillary who had better solutions? That is one of the questions that should be asked/answered in that film.

          But clearly with the names of the participants nothing close to that discussion will be happening.

  13. It’s not just twitter that is susceptible to mob psychology, propaganda or other side effects. The utopian view of free information that’s central to the hacker mindset comes with plenty shades of gray. It’s important to have those debates with an open mind imo. There are implications for transparency, accuracy, security, privacy, the ability for people to get paid, etc.

  14. Thank you for remembering and posting the link to the Brookline clinic shootings in 1994. I spoke with Leann and Shannon frequently in connection with my work on the Women’s Bar Association’s Judicial Bypass panel. As my trolley went down Beacon Street that day I absently noticed the satellite dish. Only after I arrived at my office did I receive a phone call from a friend telling me of an attack on the clinics.

    After that I became convinced that it was only a matter of time before we would have reactivate the underground.

    • But I got confused and thought “Oh no — it happened again!” and promptly sent the link to several friends before noticing the 1994 date.

      Kind of embarrassing.


Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: