• Tips gratefully accepted here. Thanks!:

  • Recent Comments

    Isabel Archer on Fully Raw Cannibals and My Oba…
    r u reddy on Krugman and I differ on O…
    mellon on Krugman and I differ on O…
    katiebird on “Keep Going”
    Yet Another Shoddy D… on Fully Raw Cannibals and My Oba…
    mellon on Krugman and I differ on O…
    Joseph Cannon on “Keep Going”
    Valentine Bonnaire on “Keep Going”
    r u reddy on Krugman and I differ on O…
    Chris S. on Krugman and I differ on O…
    Rangoon78 on Fully Raw Cannibals and My Oba…
    abc on Krugman and I differ on O…
    carol904031 on Krugman and I differ on O…
    Dwight on Krugman and I differ on O…
    katiebird on “Keep Going”
  • Categories


  • Tags

    abortion Add new tag Afghanistan Al Franken Anglachel Atrios bankers Barack Obama big pharma Bill Clinton cocktails Conflucians Say Dailykos debate Democratic Party Democrats Digby DNC Donna Brazile Economy Elizabeth Warren feminism Florida Fox News General Glenn Beck Glenn Greenwald Goldman Sachs health care Health Care Reform Hillary Clinton Howard Dean Joe Biden John Edwards John McCain Jon Corzine Karl Rove Keith Olbermann Matt Taibbi Media medicare Michelle Obama Michigan misogyny Mitt Romney Morning Edition Morning News Links Nancy Pelosi New Jersey news New York Times NO WE WON'T Obama Obamacare occupy wall street OccupyWallStreet Open thread Paul Krugman Politics Presidential Election 2008 PUMA racism Republicans Sarah Palin sexism Single Payer snark Social Security Supreme Court Terry Gross Tim Geithner unemployment Wall Street WikiLeaks women
  • Archives

  • History

    April 2014
    S M T W T F S
    « Mar    
     12345
    6789101112
    13141516171819
    20212223242526
    27282930  
  • RSS Paul Krugman: Conscience of a Liberal

  • The Confluence

    The Confluence

  • RSS Suburban Guerrilla

    • Judge boots NFL concussion settlement
      She says (and I agree) that the amount is nowhere near enough: PHILADELPHIA (AP) — A federal judge in Philadelphia has declined to approve deals for another batch of retired players suing the NFL over concussion-linked claims. U.S. District Judge Anita Brody’s preliminary ruling Wednesday follows a similar ruling in January on the proposed $765 […]
  • RSS Ian Welsh

    • Clown College as the Ukrainian military effort “sputters”
      The Ukrainian military clearly doesn’t care enough to actually fight: The day began inauspiciously for Ukrainian forces as they sought to establish an operating base in the city of Kramatorsk, moving in units from a nearby military air base. According to Ukraine’s Defense Ministry and a witness who spoke by phone, a column of six [...]
  • Top Posts

Magical Thinking is not limited to Fundamentalist Christians

I’ve been sick for over a week now with a cold.  Just when I thought I was getting over it, I’ve come down with a sore throat.  It didn’t help that so many of my relatives in Pittsburgh were sick too because I’m sure that some recombination of genetic material has been going on in my respiratory tract.  And wouldn’t you know it, I forgot to get my flu shot this year.  Stupid, stupid, stupid.

Which brings us to today’s topic: Anti-vaccers.  If you are an anti-vaccer, be forewarned that I do not intend to respect your opinion.  Because it’s stupid.  I’ll go one step further.  If you don’t believe in vaccinating yourself or your children, you are dumber than a box of rocks and twice as arrogant and careless for the well-being of others.  I don’t care who you voted for in the last election and your educational achievements only prove that some people really do not belong in college.  You are entitled to your uninformed, ignorant belief, just like fundamentalist “Christians” are entitled to their uninformed, ignorant belief about evolution but that doesn’t mean I have to respect those beliefs or give them any latitude to put other people in danger.

There is no evidence that vaccinations lead to autism.  None.  The big pharmaceutical companies are not trying to trick you into buying their dangerous product for profit.  Thimerosol doesn’t cause brain damage.  In short, just about every conspiracy theory or cause and effect urban legend has been proven wrong by study after study and retractions of studies by British medical journals.

A vaccination is simply a way of making the body generate antibodies against foreign invaders just as your body would do if it was invaded by the disease causing pathogen itself.  Vaccinations contain proteins of the disease causing pathogens and our immune systems learn to recognize these proteins and store information about them in our B cells.  These pieces of proteins can not cause the disease.  Just like anything you put in your body, there are risks of bad reactions.  But these reactions do not result in the disease  or autism, and they are very rare.

The anti-vacc crowd is getting larger.  In this edition of the podcast Ask an Atheist, Preventable Death in Washington, it is estimated that in some school districts in Washington state, up to 25% of school children are not vaccinated.  This has lead to a resurgence of Pertusis, or Whooping Cough.  An infant recently died of pertusis in Washington.

As one of the guests on the podcast says, in order for “herd immunity” to be effective, greater than 80% of the population has to be vaccinated and in the case of pertusis, it’s more like 90%.  That suggests that pertusis is pretty ubiquitous in our environment so if you’re not vaccinated, you are at risk of getting it or spreading it.

And this message is not limited to children.  Adults also need periodic boosters.  I got my adult DPT booster last year just before I was laid off.  It’s called TDAP and it’s now approved for all ages.  The other components of the booster are diphtheria and tetanus.  Before we all start thinking that tetanus, or lockjaw, is an old disease that no one ever gets anymore, consider the case of Jenny Komenda, design blogger, who contracted tetanus last fall after she constructed a side table out of rusty wire fencing material.  It sent her to the ICU and it took her awhile to recover from after she got home.

Those bugs are still out there.  And if you’re sending your kids to school unvaccinated, you might as well just put a loaded gun in their backpacks.  You never know when that sucker is going to go off or who it’s going to take down.  The rest of us have a right to peace of mind from the threat of disease just like we have the right to walk around without fear of some 2nd amendment nut and his assault rifle gunning us down.  We adults who didn’t know we needed boosters are now at risk from hundreds of thousands of disease carrying rug rats while infants and unvaccinated children are at risk from us.

I know I am not going to persuade any parent who has a emotional reaction to the issue of vaccinations because it’s impossible to reason with an irrational person.   But it’s time we take a zero tolerance approach to the anti-vacc crowd.  Back in the day, there weren’t any exemptions for anti-vaccers in school.  If you wanted your kid educated, he or she needed to have a complete shot record. Your kid couldn’t even get in the door without one.  It’s time to bring that back.  That doesn’t mean you can’t avail yourself of a free public education.  It’s just that you might have to do it from home- remotely.

To learn more about pertusis, check out The Sounds of Pertusis.

Next time in Magical Thinking is Not Limited to Fundamentalist Christians: Acupuncture, Chiropractics and Homeopathy – why should insurance companies pay for any of it?

Saturday: PSA- Vaccinations do not give you autism

Whooping Cough Epidemic Exposes Holes in CA Immunization System

But lack of them could result in a nasty case of whooping cough.

At my recent physical, my doctor recommended an adult dose of the Diptheria, Pertussis, Tetanus (DPT) shot.  She told me that so many parents were not vaccinating their kids that adults were getting pertussis, otherwise known as whooping cough.  It turns out that if you were immunized as a child, your antibody titer declines over time and you can become vulnerable to infection.  Pertussis is particularly serious in infants and as of the time the article above was posted in September 2010, 10 infants in California had died.  It’s no picnic at the beach for adults either as This Week In Google’s Gina Trapani discovered when she contacted the disease.  In fact, it sounded like she was pretty miserable and more than a little bit ticked that so many moms out there turning down the shots for their tots.

The reason many mothers don’t vaccinate their kids with the DPT combo is because of a study by Dr. Andrew Wakefield back in the 90′s that linked vaccinations to autism.  If you are one of those mothers, you should be aware that the British Medical Journal (BMJ)has retracted the study and issued an apology.  The study was fraudulent and funded by lawyers.  Yep, all true.  It was all just a big scam to soak the vaccine manufacturer for money.  Every single one of the autism cases cited by Wakefield as being tied to vaccinations were frauds.  There was no link for any of them.  All of the children in the study were either diagnosed at birth as having some kind of genetic or physical abnormality or were discovered to have some other problem around the time of the shot.  There were no cases where autism could be linked to the  shot.

Of course, if you’re a control freak mom and you don’t want to vaccinate your kid because you did not personally produce or supervise the production of the contents of the syringe, well there’s no amount of data that will convince you that you are overreacting.  (BTW, there’s no proof that thimerosol causes brain damage either)  Mothers who do not vaccinate, and let’s admit it, they’re almost always mothers, are giving the rest of us mothers a bad name.  But, whatever, if you want to let your little vectors run around unprotected, risking their lives, and those of other similarly unvaccinated kids, because you don’t want to innoculate them, that’s your business.  I think it is selfish, stupid and shows a distinct lack of knowledge of basic biology and concern for the welfare of others but I can’t exile you and your kids to an island to protect the rest of us.

What I can do is recommend that adults get the adult version of the DPT shot to protect themselves.  The sucker does leave your arm sore (Ok, VERY sore) for a couple of days but it’s better than being sidelined with whooping cough.  Right?

Do it now.

(Why any parent would risk subjecting their kid or anyone else’s kid to the symptoms shown above just defies logic)

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 415 other followers